Religion: A Force for Unity or Division?

There is both a historical and contemporary influence of religion in the world. The fact of the matter is that much of the effort to explore, to create, to understand has been a result of religious inspiration.

The philosophical musings of some of the most brilliant minds have been motivated by an attempt to understand how and why we exist.

The music of Handel, Bach, and others all were all the more memorable by their performance in the great halls of the church. Who is not touched by the ethereal sounds of a Gregorian, Buddhist, or Islamic chants and songs?

Thus the undeniable influence of religion begs for an analysis of its value to the betterment of mankind.

Whenever a person of faith speaks of their religion, they focus on the mostly good people of similar beliefs and the good done in the name of such faith. I think this does a disservice to the truth.

When it comes to religion, there is a twist on the Shakespearean line about the “good that men do….” The good done in the name of religion conceals the foundational evil. An evil that is more troubling by the willingness of most to ignore it and some to actively promote it.

Religion by its very nature is intolerant. To be a member of the Catholic Church you must embrace the tenets of the religion in its entirety. There is no such thing as doctrinal choice. Ask any priest if it is acceptable to believe in the transubstantiation of the host but not the refusal of the church to recognize same-sex marriage.

The answer is simple, no.

Religion has fought against science for centuries not out of a sense of avoiding truth but out of self-preservation. There is a direct correlation between higher educational levels and lower religiosity. That is not a coincidence, it is a well-known fact that religions have fought against over the millennia.

History is rife with examples of religious extremism. My co-writer points these out in his take on this topic; the Crusades, the Inquisition. Today we have the extremism of radical Islam. This radicalism is the best illustration of the vested interest religion has in keeping its adherents uneducated and dependent on the Imams (or priests) for their understanding of the world.

Science may not have all the answers, but science took us to the moon while religion sent two planes into the World Trade Centers.

I see the contemplative side of religion as beneficial. The power of the human mind to explore the mysteries of life is encouraging.

I see the insistence on including religion in the public square as dangerous. The competition for self-preservation is a powerful motivator. As long as religions seek support, they will seek ways to undermine ideas or societies that threaten them.

The Catholic Bishop of Rhode Island felt the need to interject himself into the Presidential campaign recently by criticizing the political philosophies of the Democratic party. In particular, their stand on abortion.

Perhaps the good Bishop should re-read (or read for the first time) the Johnson Amendment. I have no issue with the Bishop speaking as an American citizen in professing his particular political philosophy. But when he speaks as an official of the Catholic Church, for all intents and purposes he is speaking as the representative of a foreign government. There is no place for such interference in our political process.

Religion has its place in the life of many people. For them, it offers some answers to the question of our existence. It does not offer the only answer, nor does it speak to all of us.

Is religion a force for unity or division? The answer is simple. For those who hold similar beliefs, it offers unity. For those of differing philosophies, it fosters a division. I think it better that religion act as a more private, internal guide and leave the public forum to an informed but secular society.



About Joe Broadmeadow

Joe Broadmeadow retired with the rank of Captain from the East Providence Police Department after serving for 20 years. He is the author of four novels Collision Course, Silenced Justice, Saving the Last Dragon, and A Change of Hate available on Amazon in print and Kindle. Joe is working on the latest in a series of Josh Williams and Harrison "Hawk" Bennett novels and a sequel to Saving the Last Dragon. In 2014 Joe completed a 2,185 mile thru-hike of the Appalachian Trail
This entry was posted in God, Joe Broadmeadow and tagged , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Religion: A Force for Unity or Division?

  1. Good piece, Joe! But, like my parents (who didn’t follow any religious dogma) used to say – it’s because I agree with you. This made me think of an Einstein quote – “Science without religion is lame and religion without science is blind.”

    I understand that religion has, and probably always will have, an influential place in societies. That’s fine, as long as it’s conducted with common sense. Personally, I’ve very leery of anyone who is overly “religious” and it’s because of my personal observation of religious hypocrites and ignoramuses from sixty circles with this planet. My experience is the lamer someone is through religion, the blinder they are to universal truths.

    I think church is best separated from state and from science. There’s enough lameness and blindness in these two arenas without dragging religion in.

    Liked by 2 people

    • Karen says:

      I left the Catholic Church many years ago, and I completely agree that the dogma cannot be cherry-picked, even though parishioners do it all the time ^wink wink^. The contemplative aspect is very alluring though. I am sure thats true of all traditions – to joirne within is the to seek the greatest of mysteries. Luckily, we can all do this, without a priest interceding on our behalf.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s